
The Box
Directed by Richard Kelly
Just as (500) Days of Summer was a thinking person’s romantic comedy The Box is a thinking person’s sci-fi/horror film. Richard Kelly, (Donnie Darko, Southland Tales) has proven his ability for serving up cryptic socio political commentary through sci-fi and this is no different than his two previous outings (Donnie Darko and Southland Tales).
This time around Kelly works on the classic short story “Button, Button” by Richard Matheson, which was previously adapted as a Twilight Zone episode. This version is expanded to feature length by the addition of government conspiracies and visitors from outer space. The premise remains the same, a mysterious and disfigured stranger, Arlington Steward (played by Frank Langella), delivers a box with a button on it, to a young married couple in financial distress, Arthur and Norma Lewis (played by James Marsden and Cameron Diaz). If they press the button they will receive a million dollars but someone they don’t know, somewhere, will die.
This simple idea makes us ask the question. What does it mean to know someone? Do we really know anybody?
Needless to say, the button is pushed (by Norma) and with it the plot moves forward. After a couple of weird incidents a la Richard Kelly, Arthur and Norma are confronted with “technology that is indistinguishable from magic” (Arthur C. Clarke’s third law of prediction), their son is kidnapped and the mysterious Arlington Steward returns to offer them a final choice.
Since I do not want to spoil the film for anyone I will stop here.
I am a big fan of both Donnie Darko and Southland Tales and when I first found out that Richard Kelly was going to adapt “Button, Button”, I was a bit disappointed, since this was a tale I already knew and there would really be no mystery involved or cryptic storytelling to look forward to. Fortunately I was wrong, Kelly managed to go behind the button and its raison d’etre, giving us more than we could have asked out of this philosophical conundrum. To push or not to push the button. The answer should be obvious to any decent person but in a way, that is precisely the point of the “test”, as Arlington Steward calls the entire process, to find out who and how many are capable of pushing the button.
Watching the movie, the answer could be taken as misogynistic, since the three times that a button is pushed it is always done by a woman. What does this tell us about our society or about our women? Is this only because the story unfolds in the seventies?
Truth is that The Box leaves us with much to ponder and with a general feeling of uneasiness. During the climax there is a particular unpleasant feeling that seeped to my very core, a feeling rarely evoked by a movie (only Pascal Laugier’s Martyrs comes to mind). It is the realization of just how low humanity can sink and the sadness of knowing that it is all too real and all too common.
The Box is a story about the greed in humanity and what people are capable of doing because of it. In the end it is clear that the choice is ours, and that… gives us hope.




